A checked box signifies that you agree with the statement following. To
indicate that you disagree with the statement, write NO or leave blank.
| |
This manuscript is suitable for
inclusion |
|
Could paper be shortened significantly without
loss of clarity and effectiveness. If so indicate where in A above. |
|
This manuscript would
be suitable if the substantial alterations detailed above in section A are implemented. (I
do/do not wish to see the revised Ms.) |
|
Assuming the manuscript in its
original or revised form is scientifically acceptable give the paper a priority rating for
inclusion on a scale of 1 (highest) to 5 (lowest). |
| |
This manuscript is not suitable
for inclusion for the reasons detailed above in section A. |
|
Should the author wish to clarify any points
raised, I would be prepared to have him/her communicate with me. |
| |
Please return by |
|
|
I would be prepared to see this manuscript
again if the editor felt it necessary. |
